Thank you for your service, Man
A few days ago, a good friend of ours posted a picture of himself from his days working as a Specialist 4 in the 1st Battalion, 35th Infantry Regiment—also known as the "Cacti."
My wife told me I should put "Thank you for your service" under it in the comments.
"I will not," I told her.
"But why not?" was her reply.
"I don’t know for sure," I said. "It would feel awkward to me—almost like I didn't really mean it. In the Netherlands, we never say that to someone who has been in the service."
Later that week, I happened to talk to someone who arrived in the U.S. years ago; his parents moved here from Iran just before the Shah was overthrown in 1979. He told me he was probably more American than most Americans, and that he would always thank veterans for their service. I guess it’s something you grow accustomed to.
So, where does this huge difference come from? In a nutshell, it boils down to Dutch people being famously down-to-earth, and Americans being way more outgoing and expressive.
Don’t get me wrong—Dutch people do honor their veterans and fallen soldiers. It’s just not as massive or everyday; it's a quiet, respectful, and formal occasion held once a year. Veterans in the Netherlands rarely take center stage. Insignia and medals are only worn during special ceremonies, nor do they get the kind of everyday privileges you see over here, where people wear their veteran status proudly on hats and license plates and receive all sorts of discounts and benefits.
Where in the U.S. the armed forces are key to patriotism, personal identity, and the American narrative, in the Netherlands the military is simply seen as a professional public service and an employer—rather than the shield of the nation.
Part of this stems from the consensus that American soldiers are actively defending the freedom of the U.S.—"You need me on that wall," as Jack Nicholson famously said in A Few Good Men—whereas the Dutch army is usually more neutral and peacekeeping-oriented under a UN or NATO flag.
So what else is key to this "hero worship"? Whereas the Netherlands is very much an "act normal, and you're already acting weird enough" kind of country, Americans love their heroes. Dutch people will pull you back down to keep you grounded; Americans will put you on a pedestal if you excel. And that makes sense—after all, this is the land of unlimited possibilities. Whether it’s celebrities, athletes, or entrepreneurs, at some point they are viewed as visionaries or take on an almost mythological status.
Add that moral greatness to a soldier who is willing to lay down his life for you, and you have your ultimate hero. It also fits in nicely with the classic "Good Guy vs. Bad Guy" narrative woven into American culture. On top of that, it is heavily commercialized—whether it’s corporations loudly advertising their support for veterans, or the veteran tributes and flyovers at sporting events that tie entertainment directly into patriotism.
I could go on about this and make the bridge to trophy culture, too, but I’ll save that for another blog.
So where does that leave me? I am a person who questions a lot, and I do my research, because there is a lot I don’t know or understand yet. The downside of that is that I also read the bad stuff—the state of healthcare and the VA system, and how despite the patriotic front toward veterans, there is still a lot left to be done. What also surprised me was the existence of the Stolen Valor Act. The first version dealt with lying about receiving medals and decorations, but was deemed unconstitutional due to freedom of speech. So they came up with a revised version that made it a crime when used for financial or material gain, aimed specifically at the highest and most heroic decorations. In the Netherlands, it is simply not allowed by law to wear any commendation or uniform that you did not earn.
Thankfully, I have a wife who will walk right up to a veteran and thank him (or her) for their service, regardless of whether they were on the front line or "just" a cook. I've seen her explain that the cook is just as important as anyone else, and honestly, you can see it does them good. Sometimes, when we have the time, we get to hear a story or two—and they're usually fascinating. That’s something that most likely would never happen in the Netherlands.
The ease with which she does that baffles me sometimes. And then there’s me standing there, getting drawn into the conversation, asking questions and being genuinely interested, yet still feeling too awkward to utter those five words.
I now realize that part of Dutch culture is embedded deeply in me, and since I’m over 60 now, it is not easily molded into the American way. But I’m starting to get it. Cultural learning takes time, so I guess this is my first step.
Thank you for your service.